Skinny Orange Pitcher Margaritas Recipe

If you asked me to pick one drink for the rest of my life, I think I’d have to go with margaritas. I mean, they’re so versatile so if you chose margaritas you’d have basically endless possibilities. As solid as picking tacos or pizza for your one food, right?

For cinco de mayo, I obviously couldn’t not serve margaritas, right? Plus, margaritas are a perfect cocktail for a crowd. You can whip up a pitcher so easily, taste and adjust as necessary and guests can serve themselves. I’ll be honest, I set out to make a good ol’ skinny margarita using OJ instead of triple sec or cointreau. Then, I really just went for that orange-forward flavor. They were deeeeelish!

Alright, so, you know by now I have a deep love and obsession with salt. So, to be honest, I think I love margaritas so much because it’s (relatively) acceptable to lick the rim of your glass – if it’s not, never tell me. A margarita is a vehicle for salt!

I love a heavily salted rim – whenever we are out and I order a margarita I tell them heavy on the salt. Here for it. If you’re not, skip it! I would recommend that you only leave the lime wedge on the rim and the cocktail salt to the side for your guests. This way, if they want to salt the rim of their glass they can use the lime wedge and dunk to get the amount of salt they want. If they don’t want salt, then they’ve got a cute little lime wedge on their glass.

I mean, just lookkkk at that salt! You know this girl has made your cocktail if there’s an inch of salt on your rim. (Swear I don’t salt this heavily – hubby was talking to me as I was dipping them and I went way too far down!)

So anyway! You can make just about any flavor of marg a skinny marg if you stick to just blanco tequilla, lemon, lime, fruit flavor/juice (went with unsweetened fresh OJ for these) and skip the sugar. Or, you can add a little bit of sugar with liquid stevia, agave, sweetened lime juice or simple syrup. But I would say, never skip the salt. xo

What’s your favorite margarita?

Skinny Orange Pitcher Margaritas

What’s better than a fresh margarita in a pitcher for guests to serve themselves! With fresh juices, blanco tequila and lots of salt, these are the perfect addition to any party, from a cinco de mayo fiesta and beyond!
Cook Time 10 mins
Course Cocktail
Servings 6 servings


  • 12 oz blanco tequila or more – you do you!
  • 2 limes, juiced
  • 1 lemon, juiced
  • 1-2 c fresh squeezed OJ without sugar
  • club soda/seltzer
  • agave, simple syrup, sweetened lime juice, liquid stevia, etc.
  • limes, salt, ice for serving


  • Combine tequila and citrus juices in a pitcher; stir to combine. 
  • Add seltzer to fill up pitcher and gently stir (you don’t want to create too much foam so as to avoid an overflow).
  • Taste for sugar and add a liquid sugar or sugar substitute if desired.
  • Serve glasses with lime wedges and allow guests to rim glasses with lime wedge and dunk in salt if they desire. 

Leave a comment

Please be polite. We appreciate that. Your email address will not be published and required fields are marked

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.